Write-once media
Storage that physically or logically prevents rewriting committed regions.
Write-once media are storage media whose recording step cannot be undone, so a committed region can be read any number of times but never overwritten. In optical form the recording step is typically a laser heating a thin film so that it melts or ablates into a non-reflective mark (course notes on optical disks; the SEC's 1997 rule release describes WORM optical storage as a laser heat source burning a pattern on a metallic film), and the SEC release lists alloying, bubble-forming, moth-eye (Plasmon), phase-change, dye/polymer and magneto-optic methods as other write-once approaches. Dated milestones from sources opened: an Optimem (division of Shugart) paper at the April 1984 Optical Data Storage meeting describes the Optimem 1000 as a write-once drive of 1 GB per surface; the IBM 3363 Optical Disk Drive was announced on 2 April 1987 for IBM PCs and PS/2 systems, with a 130 mm (5.25-inch) removable write-once cartridge of 200 MB (vendor claim), a spiral format of 512-byte sectors, 23 sectors per track and 17,100 tracks (about 201 million bytes by arithmetic on those figures), and IBM-stated average seek under 230 ms across one-third of the disk (vendor claim); Computer History Museum catalogues 3363 units made in February and November 1987. IBM's DOS file driver made the drive appear rewritable by keeping earlier versions of a file, which IBM described as an automatic audit trail (vendor claim). A 1990 trade report credited Information Storage Inc. (ISI) as a pioneer of WORM drives, with 1.28 GB on a 5.25-inch disk, and said the 5.25-inch WORM market never really took off and was slowed by erasable magneto-optical units (the newsletter's opinion). A May 1991 trade report said IBM was replacing 12-inch WORM optical disks and jukeboxes in its ImagePlus catalogue with 5.25-inch media in the 3995 Optical Library Dataservers, at 610 MB per cartridge over both sides, because smaller disks turn faster and have many suppliers (IBM executive's explanation); the new products were not due before June 1992. CD-R carried the model to the compact disc: Taiyo Yuden's Takashi Ishiguro, who developed it, dates the first working recording to 13 June 1988 and describes a polycarbonate disc with a pre-molded guide groove, an organic dye layer, a gold or silver reflector and a protective coat, where the recording laser forms marks by dye decomposition plus substrate deformation, and he gives capacity as growing from 530 MB (63 min) to the standard's 700 MB (80 min) limit. CD-R is specified in Part II of the Orange Book by Philips and Sony and was first called CD-WO; Ishiguro says standardisation with Philips and Sony followed in 1989, while a Philips paper abstract says the first Orange Book draft was published in November 1990, so the sources disagree on the standardisation date and this record does not resolve it. Regulation was a documented driver in the United States: the Securities Industry Association asked the SEC staff in 1991 to allow electronic storage and in May 1992 asked for a no-action position on optical disk with WORM safeguards; the staff issued a no-action letter on 18 June 1993 and the SEC proposed a rule on 9 July 1993. The SEC adopted amendments to Rule 17a-4(f) in February 1997 (Federal Register 12 February 1997, effective 14 April 1997; a 2022 SEC release cites the adopting release as dated 31 January 1997), requiring broker-dealers using electronic storage media to preserve records exclusively in a non-rewriteable, non-erasable format, verify recording automatically, serialize and time-date media, index and duplicate records, and use a third-party download undertaking, while explicitly not limiting the media to optical disk (optical tape and WORM CD-ROM were named). A 2001 SEC interpretation found those requirements consistent with the E-SIGN Act, and per the 2022 release a 2003 interpretation clarified that WORM does not mandate optical disks. Amendments adopted on 12 October 2022 (effective 3 January 2023, compliance date 3 May 2023) kept WORM as an option and added an audit-trail alternative that must permit re-creation of an original record if it is modified or deleted. This record covers only SEC Rule 17a-4 and does not describe other regulators' rules.
Relations
- related
- WORM storage, Optical archival storage, Storage immutability, Optical jukebox, Magneto-optical disc, Magnetic tape storage, DNA data storage, CD block error rate (BLER)
Advantages
- Committed data cannot be altered by later writes, which the SEC accepted as an integrity safeguard: its 1997 amendment to Rule 17a-4(f) required electronic storage media to preserve records exclusively in a non-rewriteable, non-erasable format. [11, 12]
- Removable cartridges let the written volume be stored away from the drive; IBM positioned the 3363 for security, archive and backup uses where removability matters (vendor claim). [2]
- CD-R was designed so that discs written to the Orange Book play in CD players made before CD-R existed, per its developer (vendor claim). [8]
- The IBM 3363 file driver kept earlier versions of a file, which IBM said gave users an automatic audit trail and archive (vendor claim). [2]
Limitations
- Written regions cannot be erased or rewritten, so file systems must append: the IBM 3363 driver made the drive appear rewritable only by keeping old versions, and CD-R discs are written in sessions and can be finalised so that no further writes are accepted. [2, 9]
- Defects on write-once media show up only when data is written: course notes describe direct-read-after-write, with a block that fails verification rewritten in the next block, and give bit error rates of about 10^-6 for optical media versus 10^-8 for magnetic media in the mid-1990s (single source, course notes). The SEC rule likewise required automatic verification of the recording process. [7, 11]
- Capacity per disc is bounded by the standard: CD-R grew only from 530 MB (63 min) at its start to the Orange Book limit of 700 MB (80 min), per its developer (vendor claim); 5.25-inch WORM drives were reported in 1990 to have been slowed by erasable magneto-optical units (trade-press opinion). [8, 5]
- Media formats were fragmented: IBM moved its ImagePlus optical offering from 12-inch to 5.25-inch WORM media in 1991, with different cartridge capacities per generation. [6, 2]
- WORM is no longer the only way to meet SEC Rule 17a-4 for electronic records: the October 2022 amendments added an audit-trail alternative, effective 3 January 2023 with compliance on 3 May 2023. [13, 14]
Citations
- IBM Announcement Letter 187-064: IBM 3363 Optical Disk Drive (2 April 1987; mirror)
- The Optimem 1000 Optical Disk Drive, G. R. Knight, Optical Data Storage 1984 (abstract)
- History (1990): New International Consortium in Optical Disks, StorageNewsletter
- History (1991): IBM Gives Up 12-Inch Optical Discs for 5.25-Inch Media, StorageNewsletter
- Chapter 12. Optical Disks, Computer Peripherals course notes (Nanyang Technological University)
- CD-R development story, T. Ishiguro, Taiyo Yuden, Oyo Buturi 81(8), 2012 (Japanese)
- CD-R (Wikipedia)
- SEC Release 34-38245, Federal Register 62 FR 6469 (12 Feb 1997)
- SEC Release 34-44238: Guidance on electronic storage media and Rule 17a-4(f) (1 May 2001)
- SEC: Amendments to Electronic Recordkeeping Requirements for Broker-Dealers (small entity compliance guide, 28 Feb 2023)
- SEC Release 34-96034: Electronic Recordkeeping Requirements for Broker-Dealers (12 Oct 2022)