Bit error rate
Bit error rate (BER) expresses erroneous bits relative to the total bits considered at a specified observation point.
A communications-security glossary defines the ratio as incorrectly received bits over bits transmitted through a channel and notes that it also applies to storage. [2] The observation point, sample size and interval have to be stated, because the term alone does not mean before error correction. A field study of flash drives defines raw bit error rate as corrupted bits per total bits read, counting both correctable and uncorrectable events. [7]
Counting conventions change the figure. In the first drive generation of that study each page of 16 data chunks reported only the corrupted-bit count of its worst chunk, so true RBER could be up to 16 times higher than recorded. Median RBER across models ranged from 5.8e-10 to more than 3e-08, and the 99th percentile of a model was typically at least ten times its median. [7]
After correction, a flash survey defines the uncorrectable bit error rate as the codeword failure rate divided by codeword length. In its example a BCH code with rate 0.935 stays within a 10^-16 UBER target up to an RBER of 1.0e-3, while soft-decision LDPC with rate 0.936 reaches 5.0e-3 at the cost of extra reads. [3]
Relations
- related
- LDPC (NAND ECC), NAND flash, Hard disk drive (HDD), Reed–Solomon codes (storage), Error-correcting code, Codeword (storage ECC), Raw bit error rate, Uncorrectable bit error rate
Advantages
- Normalizing by bits read lets error levels be compared across drives that use the same reporting convention. [7]
Limitations
- Raw BER and post-correction outcomes are distinct; a codeword failure ratio is not itself a count of erroneous bits. [3]
- Fleet averages are dominated by a few outlier drives, so medians and percentiles describe field data better. [7]
Citations
- NIST CSRC glossary: bit error rate, citing CNSSI 4009-2022.
- Cai, Ghose, Haratsch, Luo and Mutlu. Error Characterization, Mitigation, and Recovery in Flash Memory Based SSDs. arXiv:1706.08642, 2017, sections 6.2-6.3.
- Schroeder, Lagisetty and Merchant. Flash Reliability in Production: The Expected and the Unexpected. USENIX FAST 2016, sections 4 and 5.2-5.3.
Further reading
- Bit error rate
- Hesela: LDPC in NAND, the read cost of confidence
- SNIA Dictionary: bit error rate.
- Solidigm D7-P5810 product brief, page 3 reliability table and page 4 qualification note.
Sources & caveats
- nist is the NIST CSRC glossary entry citing CNSSI 4009-2022, re-read for the channel definition and its storage scope.
- schroeder2016 is the FAST 2016 field study, re-read for the RBER definition, the worst-chunk reporting caveat and the Table 3 range.
- cai2017 is arXiv:1706.08642, re-read in sections 6.2-6.3 for the UBER definition and the BCH and LDPC example.
- The soft-decision-decoding entry links here because the example shows soft LDPC tolerating a higher raw error rate within the same UBER target.