NAND page scrubbing
NAND page scrubbing reprograms a physical flash page to obscure its previous digital contents without erasing the whole block.
In the FAST 2011 design, remaining one bits are programmed to zero. This is a deletion operation, unlike integrity scrubbing, which checks stored data for errors. A host overwrite need not reach the same physical page because the FTL can redirect it. [1]
Reprogramming can disturb other data. The studied MLC devices required paired-page handling and a device-specific scrub budget, after which valid data were relocated and the block erased. [1]
An all-zero readout can still conceal different cell histories. Hasan and Ray showed that retention separates old and newly programmed zeros; partial erase exposed this difference on tested SLC chips. Their setup bypassed the FTL and read raw bits without ECC. Two of four listed chip models had recovery figures; the other two exceeded the setup's timing capability. [2]
The proposed analog scrubbing uses partial programming to reduce that separation. Its calibration depends on retention history; the paper leaves accurate timing characterization for future investigation. An unrecognizable recovered image is not a general proof of secure deletion. [2]
Relations
- related
- Data scrubbing, Data sanitization, Secure erase, NAND page, NAND erase block, NAND program interference, Flash data retention, Flash translation layer (FTL)
Limitations
- These experiments do not establish recovery rates for modern 3D TLC or QLC SSDs or validate an NVMe Sanitize implementation. [2, 1]
Citations
- Wei et al. Reliably Erasing Data from Flash-Based Solid State Drives. FAST 2011, sections 4.2-4.4.
- Hasan and Ray. Data Recovery from Scrubbed NAND Flash Storage: Need for Analog Sanitization. USENIX Security 2020, sections 3-6.
Sources & caveats
- Primary-paper synthesis, not a new recovery experiment. The 2020 demonstration used accelerated retention at 120 C; no conversion to ordinary storage years is assumed. [2]